Oaken & Pike Campaign recap · Autumn 2026

Autumn campaign recap Marlow Coffee

Eight weeks of “Slow Mornings”, 1 September – 26 October 2026, in one document: the result, where the money went, what missed, and the three bets we would make next.

Client
Marlow Coffee
Campaign
“Slow Mornings”, autumn 2026
Period
8 weeks, 1 Sep – 26 Oct 2026
Prepared by
Oaken & Pike · Ines Varga, account lead · Tobias Renn, performance
Issued
3 November 2026 · Version 1.0

The headline result

+42%

click-through against the spring campaign.

3.1% of the people who saw the work clicked, against 2.2% in March–April. The campaign came in €2,000 under its €120,000 budget, reached 2.4 million people and brought 8,310 new customers at €14.20 each, 22% cheaper than in spring.

The numbers that matter

Spend €118k of the €120k budget · 98% used
Reach 2.4M people · 1.9M in spring · up 26%
Click-through 3.1% 2.2% in spring · up 42%
Cost per customer €14.20 €18.20 in spring · down 22%
New customers 8,310 6,040 in spring · up 38%
Repeat purchase 40% within 30 days · 31% in spring · up 9 pt

Week by week

New customers per week, first orders attributed as described under the channel table. The dashed line is the weekly average of the spring campaign, 755 new customers a week. From week 2 the autumn campaign never dropped below it.

Spring weekly average, 755 new customers 2,000 1,500 1,000 500 0 640 790 880 950 1,010 1,870 1,160 1,010 W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 1 Sep 8 Sep 15 Sep 22 Sep 29 Sep 6 Oct 13 Oct 20 Oct Creator post, 7 Oct, plus €6k moved behind it. 22% of all new customers.
Figure 1 · New customers per week against the spring weekly average. Week 6, highlighted, brought 1,870 new customers, 22% of the campaign total. One of the six creators posted an unscripted follow-up about her morning routine on Wednesday 7 October; it reached 640,000 people in four days and we moved €6,000 of paid social behind it within 48 hours. Week 1 is the only week below the spring line.

Where the money went

Five channels, one currency: the cost of a new customer. Creators were the cheapest paid customer of the campaign. Out-of-home took 17% of the spend and delivered 5% of the customers.

Spend and new customers by channel, weeks 1 to 8
Channel Spend New customers Share of customers Cost per customer Cost vs spring
Paid social €52,000 3,900 47% €13.33 down 26%
Search €24,000 1,850 22% €12.97 down 8%
Creator €18,000 1,540 19% €11.69 down 40%
Email €4,000 620 7% €6.45 down 9%
Out-of-home €20,000 400 5% €50.00 up 8%
Total €118,000 8,310 100% €14.20 down 22%

Attribution: last paid touch within seven days for paid social and search; creator codes and links for creator; order-level for email, counting first orders from subscribers who had not bought before; post-purchase survey for out-of-home. Cost vs spring compares with the March–April 2026 campaign, same method.

What worked

  1. Creators beat every paid channel on cost

    Six creators, €18,000, 1,540 new customers at €11.69 each. The week-6 video was not in the brief: the creator posted a second, unscripted piece about her morning routine and it reached 640,000 people in four days. The two best-performing creator pieces of the campaign were both outside the shot list we gave them.

  2. Moving the budget every Monday

    We reviewed spend weekly and moved €7,000 between lines, out of out-of-home and brand search and into paid social and creators, plus a further €9,000 inside paid social from the “origin” creative set (2.4% click-through) to the “ritual” set (4.2%). Click-through stood at 2.6% at the end of week 2 and finished at 3.1%; the reallocation is most of the difference.

  3. Email did the repeat work

    The three-send “second bag” sequence, sent 5, 12 and 20 days after a first order, cost €4,000 and lifted repeat purchase within 30 days from 31% to 40%. It is the reason the +9 pt sits next to the acquisition numbers rather than behind them.

What did not

  1. Out-of-home did not pay back

    €20,000 across three cities in two flights; we cancelled the third. By post-purchase survey, 400 new customers named the posters as where they first saw Marlow: €50 per customer, 3.5 times the blended figure, on the weakest attribution in the table. We do not recommend out-of-home again at this scale, and bet 3 below is the small test that would settle it.

  2. Week 1 underperformed, and that is on us

    640 new customers, below the spring weekly average of 755. The landing page shipped three days late and the first two creatives went live without a test; the “origin” set opened at 2.1% click-through. Our estimate is around 300 customers lost, most of them in the first four days.

What we learned

  • Creative choice moved results more than bidding. Between the two creative sets, click-through differed by 1.8 pt. No bid or audience change during the eight weeks moved it by more than 0.3 pt.
  • Brief the ritual, not the shot list. Both breakout creator pieces were unscripted. The winter brief should describe the morning we want people to recognise and leave the framing to the creator.
  • The offer mattered less than the hour. “First bag €9” and “free shipping on the first three bags” performed within 4% of each other. Posts published between 06:00 and 08:00 outperformed the same creative published after 17:00 by 31% on click-through.
  • Attribution is now the weakest part of the setup. Paid social, search and email numbers are defensible. Creator and out-of-home rest on codes and a one-question survey that 4,900 of the 8,310 new customers answered. Bet 3 includes a tracked offer for that reason.

Next bets

Three proposals for the winter campaign, each with a cost, the effect we expect, and the rule we would use to stop it.

Proposed bets for winter 2026 to 2027
Bet Cost Expected effect Decision rule
1 · Twelve creators for winter, up from six, briefed on the ritual €36,000 About 3,000 new customers at €13 or less each, and two more posts of week-6 scale Continue only if cost per customer is under €15 at the end of week 4
2 · Always-on “second bag” sequence, email plus SMS €6,000 Repeat purchase within 30 days from 40% to 44%; cost covers the build and three months of sends Drop the SMS leg if unsubscribes exceed 1.5% on any send
3 · One out-of-home format only: station panels near the two Marlow cafés, with a QR-tracked offer €8,000 A clean read on whether out-of-home can reach €25 per customer, with attribution we can defend Remove out-of-home from 2027 plans if it lands above €25

Budget against spend

€118,000 spent of €120,000. The variances are the Monday reallocations described above; contingency covered €1,000 of the creator top-up and the rest was not needed.

Budget and spend by line, media and creator fees excluding VAT
Line Budget Spend Variance Why
Paid social €48,000 €52,000 +€4,000 Reallocated from out-of-home in weeks 5 to 8, behind the “ritual” set and the week-6 creator post
Search €26,000 €24,000 −€2,000 Brand terms capped from week 4; 70% of brand clicks came from people who had already bought
Creator €15,000 €18,000 +€3,000 Two creators added in week 3, and usage rights for the week-6 video
Email €4,000 €4,000 €0 As planned
Out-of-home €24,000 €20,000 −€4,000 Third flight in week 7 cancelled
Contingency €3,000 €0 −€3,000 €1,000 released to the creator line; €2,000 unspent
Total €120,000 €118,000 −€2,000 98.3% of budget spent

Notes on the numbers

  • Window. 1 September – 26 October 2026, with a seven-day attribution tail to 2 November. Spring comparison: 2 March – 26 April 2026, same method.
  • Click-through. 189,000 clicks on 6.1 million paid impressions across paid social, search, creator and email. Spring: 103,000 clicks on 4.7 million impressions.
  • Reach. De-duplicated people across the four digital channels, from platform reporting. The out-of-home audience is estimated by the media owner and is not included.
  • New customers. First orders in Marlow’s order export, matched to a channel as described under the channel table.
  • Repeat purchase. Share of new customers who ordered again within 30 days. Measured on weeks 1 to 4 customers (3,260) against the same window in spring; weeks 5 to 8 will be added in the December update.
  • Money. Media and creator fees, excluding VAT. The Oaken & Pike retainer is billed separately and is not part of the €118,000.